16:9 in English
16:9 is a Danish journal of film studies. Each issue features an article in English by a renowned film scholar.
Please contact editor Jakob
Isak Nielsen or editor Jan
Oxholm for more information or if you have material that
you want us to consider for publication.
Peer review
16:9’s peer review process is double-blind. It applies to articles only.
The peer review is presented in the form of grading system from A to D:
A. Publishable
B. Publishable with minor alterations
C. Publishable with major alterations
D. Not publishable
The grade will be accompanied by a brief review (approximately 1-2 pages) that includes all suggested alterations. The following questions will be the focus of the review:
- Is the topic clearly articulated?
- Does the article raise relevant questions?
- Is the article written in a clear language?
- Is new information brought to light?
- Is the article interesting from a methodological and/or theoretical perspective?
- Is the argumentation clear and precise?
- Are the headings good and catchy?
- How can the article be improved (e.g. structure, readibility, topics, sources)?
- Other comments
|
